--- title: Choose a Pool or a Plan Before Succession | Case Study description: How a public institution tested its criticality grid on 280 positions, cut it from 9 criteria to 4, and gave succession 2 routes and one owner per step. image: https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hubfs/social-sharing/cases/case-critical-positions-and-succession-management-at-a-public-institution.jpg --- [Skip to content](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/critical-positions-and-succession-management-at-a-public-institution#main-content) [![PeopleCentrix](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hubfs/assets/images/peoplecentrix-logo.svg "PeopleCentrix")](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/) [LET'S CONNECT →](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/work-with-us) - [People Strategy](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-strategy) - [People Centricity](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-centricity) - [How We Work](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/how-we-work) - [Insights](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-thinking) Show submenu for Insights - [Our Work](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) - [Our Thinking](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-thinking) - [About Us](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us) - [Work With Us](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/work-with-us) - [People Strategy](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-strategy) - [People Centricity](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-centricity) - [How We Work](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/how-we-work) - [Insights](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-thinking) Show submenu for Insights - [Our Work](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) - [Our Thinking](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-thinking) - [About Us](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us) - [Work With Us](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/work-with-us) People Centricity case study # Choose *a Pool or a Plan* Before You Design Succession **280**real positions used to test the criticality grid **77%**of positions classified the same with fewer than half the criteria **42**activities, each with one owner, in the succession process **27**indicators, each with an owner, from mapping to retention Snapshot Client A public institution (anonymised) Sector, size, geography Local Public Sector; 10,000+ staff; Europe, organised in departments each run by its own management team Engagement People Centricity · Unleash Our role Co-created succession governance with the institution’s talent team — criticality grid test, benchmark, pilot lessons, 5-step process with 2 routes, responsibility matrix, indicators and scenarios to 2030; roll-out by the client Mode of engagement Co-created Timeframe 2025–2026 Project duration 3–6 months · 4 steps: test the grid, look outside and back, design the governance, plan the scale-up; roll-out by the client The situation ## The question behind *the question.* Succession was one of the initiatives of this institution’s [six-year people strategy](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/people-strategy-2023-2028-at-a-public-institution), and time was short. A quarter of its senior managers were due to retire within 5 years, and in some departments every head of service would change within 3. The labour market offered little cover: the country expects to be short of tens of thousands of nurses and doctors by 2040. Its talent team had already built a criticality grid and run nursing pilots. It lacked a model that would hold across a matrix of directorates and departments, and proof its grid measured the right things. As it was asked “Review our approach and propose a governance model for succession.” As we reframed it Test the criticality grid before redesigning anything, learn from peers and from our own pilots, then give succession one process, 2 routes and one owner for every step in the matrix. How we worked ## How the work *unfolded.* 01 ### Test the grid We started with the evidence the team already had. Its grid scored 9 criteria; we tested 4 on 280 real positions from 14 medical and nursing units: the impact of the post and of its vacancy, the rarity of its skills, and the time a newcomer needs to work alone. Each was scored 1 to 3 against anchors in months: a post refilled within 3 months scores 1, one that takes a year or more scores 3. With fewer than half the criteria, 77% of positions landed in the same class, a correlation of 0.89. 02 ### Look outside and back Then 2 sources of lessons. Some 45 organisations were approached and the closest peers interviewed in depth: a university hospital group, a technical university and 2 national employers, all steering from the centre while managers own the outcome. The institution’s own nursing pilots were then scored step by step with their owners: mapping positions and supporting development were weakest, and the tools would not scale. 03 ### Design the governance Then the process, worked through with the HR business partners and the talent team: 5 steps from mapping to recruiting, and one choice at the start, a talent pool where roles share skills, a career plan where a role is unique. A nurse manager answers to a department and to the nursing directorate; without a rule, succession belongs to both, so to neither. A 42-activity matrix gave every step one owner across that double line. The top band was raised and crossed with how soon a post falls vacant, and each successor got a readiness level and a development plan. 04 ### Plan the scale-up Then the scale. Succession covered about 7% of positions, and only on request. 3 scenarios to 2030 raised coverage to a quarter, a half or every critical post, each weighed against the central team’s workload and the training budget. 27 indicators, each with an owner and a 6-month rhythm, ran from positions mapped to critical posts with no successor. The spreadsheet had reached its limits, so the system requirements were set out too. The instrument ### Pool or plan **A pool.** Where several roles share the same skills, develop a group of candidates, any of whom can step in. **A plan.** Where a role is unique, name its successors, give each a readiness level and a development plan. **The choice.** Made at mapping, by the department with HR, before anyone is named. The pool develops people for families of roles; the plan protects the few roles no one else can do. Choose first, and the process follows. What moved ## What changed, *and what didn't.* **4**criteria now rate every key position, down from 9 Evidence Decision taken Adopted in practice Measured impact What moved The institution now rates its key positions on **4** criteria instead of 9, prioritised by how soon each will fall vacant. The governance runs as designed: the talent service guards the method, HR business partners lead, departments shortlist through their career committees, and both routes, talent pools and career plans, are in use. What didn't move When we handed over, no scale-up scenario had been chosen and most of the 27 indicators were not yet produced. The pilots filled every succession internally, leaving the balance with external hiring open, and the system that would replace the spreadsheet was still to come. Future importance was dropped as a criterion, so the grid reads today’s roles better than tomorrow’s. What we'd say to a peer Before you redesign succession, test the grid you already have: if 4 criteria give the same answer as 9, keep 4 and spend the effort on what follows. Then build pools where roles share skills, career plans where a role is unique, and give every step one owner across the matrix. [Let's talk](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/work-with-us) [Discover People Centricity](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-centricity) [Read more cases](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) **Method note:** Own approach in 4 steps; 9- versus 4-criterion test on 280 positions; external benchmark; pilot lessons learned; 5-step process with 2 routes; 42-activity responsibility matrix; 27 indicators; deployment scenarios. ## Keep reading [![Price Your Training Ambition Before You Choose It](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hs-fs/hubfs/social-sharing/cases/case-learning-and-development-strategy-at-a-public-institution.jpg?width=300&name=case-learning-and-development-strategy-at-a-public-institution.jpg)](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/learning-and-development-strategy-at-a-public-institution) ###### [Our Work,](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work)[Case Study](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) ##### [Price Your Training Ambition Before You Choose It](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/learning-and-development-strategy-at-a-public-institution) [Tanguy Dulac](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us) [Read More](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/learning-and-development-strategy-at-a-public-institution) [![A People Strategy That Listened to Every Shift](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hs-fs/hubfs/social-sharing/cases/case-people-strategy-2026-2031-at-a-multilateral-organisation.jpg?width=300&name=case-people-strategy-2026-2031-at-a-multilateral-organisation.jpg)](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/people-strategy-2026-2031-at-a-multilateral-organisation) ###### [Our Work,](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work)[Case Study](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) ##### [A People Strategy That Listened to Every Shift](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/people-strategy-2026-2031-at-a-multilateral-organisation) [Tanguy Dulac](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us) [Read More](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/people-strategy-2026-2031-at-a-multilateral-organisation) [![A People Strategy Boards Could Fund, Not Just Approve](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hs-fs/hubfs/social-sharing/cases/case-people-strategy-2023-2028-at-a-public-institution.jpg?width=300&name=case-people-strategy-2023-2028-at-a-public-institution.jpg)](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/people-strategy-2023-2028-at-a-public-institution) ###### [Our Work,](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work)[Case Study](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) ##### [A People Strategy Boards Could Fund, Not Just Approve](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/people-strategy-2023-2028-at-a-public-institution) [Tanguy Dulac](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us) [Read More](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/people-strategy-2023-2028-at-a-public-institution) WeAreHuman@Work One piece of evidence on sustainable work, every Sunday. Free, and one click to leave. [Get the weekly edition](https://www.wearehumanatwork.com/) ##### ![logo-white-ls-sample-theme](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hubfs/raw_assets/public/popular-theme-v2/assets/images/peoplecentrix-footer-logo.svg) We help HR leaders turn people investment into measurable results — strategies that get approved, interventions that get delivered, impact that gets proven. ##### Follow Us [Follow us on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoplecentrixconsulting/) ##### Quick Links - [Home](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/en/) - [People Strategy](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-strategy) - [People Centricity](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-centricity) - [How We Work](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/how-we-work) - [Our Client Case Studies](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) - [Our Thinking](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-thinking) - [About Us](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us) - [Work With Us](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/work-with-us) ##### Contact PeopleCentriX Geneva, Switzerland    [tanguy.dulac@peoplecentrix.eu](mailto:info@peoplecentrix.eu) --- Copyright © 2026 PeopleCentriX SARL. All rights reserved. PeopleCentriX name and logo are registered trademarks of PeopleCentriX SARL. - [Privacy statement](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/en/privacy-page) ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#organization", "@type" : [ "ProfessionalService", "Organization" ], "address" : { "@type" : "PostalAddress", "addressCountry" : "CH", "addressLocality" : "Founex", "addressRegion" : "Vaud", "postalCode" : "1297", "streetAddress" : "Chemin du Lac 19A" }, "alternateName" : [ "PeopleCentriX Consulting", "PeopleCentriX SARL" ], "areaServed" : [ "Worldwide", "International organisations", "Private sector", "Public sector" ], "audience" : [ { "@type" : "Audience", "audienceType" : "Chief People Officers and Chief Human Resources Officers" }, { "@type" : "Audience", "audienceType" : "Chief Talent Officers and Heads of Talent Management" } ], "contactPoint" : { "@type" : "ContactPoint", "availableLanguage" : [ "English", "French" ], "contactType" : "sales", "email" : "tanguy.dulac@peoplecentrix.eu", "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/work-with-us" }, "description" : "PeopleCentriX is an evidence-based people-strategy advisory founded in Switzerland in March 2022 by Tanguy Dulac, PhD. It serves Chief People Officers defining, activating and proving a board-approved people strategy, and Chief Talent Officers attracting, engaging and unleashing talent through focused people-centricity interventions. It helps both turn people investment into measurable results — strategies that get approved, interventions that get delivered, impact that gets proven.", "email" : "tanguy.dulac@peoplecentrix.eu", "employee" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#tanguy-dulac" }, "founder" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#tanguy-dulac" }, "foundingDate" : "2022-03", "foundingLocation" : { "@type" : "Place", "name" : "Founex, Vaud, Switzerland" }, "hasOfferCatalog" : { "@type" : "OfferCatalog", "itemListElement" : [ { "@type" : "Offer", "itemOffered" : { "@type" : "Service", "audience" : { "@type" : "Audience", "audienceType" : "Chief People Officers" }, "description" : "Define, Activate, Prove — the sparring partner for the Chief People Officer carrying the board mandate: build the evidence base and business case, govern implementation from inside the programme office, and prove what the investment returned against baselines set before the work starts.", "name" : "People Strategy", "provider" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#organization" }, "serviceType" : "People strategy advisory", "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-strategy" } }, { "@type" : "Offer", "itemOffered" : { "@type" : "Service", "audience" : { "@type" : "Audience", "audienceType" : "Chief Talent Officers" }, "description" : "Attract, Engage, Unleash — focused interventions for Chief Talent Officers, each targeting one component of the People Centricity Formula™: an employee value proposition built on researched expectations, moments that matter redesigned, and talent frameworks that develop potential. Closed when solved.", "name" : "People Centricity", "provider" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#organization" }, "serviceType" : "Talent and employee-experience interventions", "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-centricity" } } ], "name" : "PeopleCentriX offerings" }, "image" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hubfs/assets/images/peoplecentrix-logo.svg", "knowsAbout" : [ "People strategy", "People centricity", "Programme management", "Change management", "Business case", "HR metrics", "People analytics", "Employee attraction", "Employee experience", "Employee engagement", "Design thinking", "Human-centred design in HR", "HR operating model", "Human capital risk management", "People risks", "Human sustainability", "People sustainability", "Talent management", "Talent strategy" ], "knowsLanguage" : [ "en", "fr" ], "legalName" : "PeopleCentriX Sàrl", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "caption" : "PeopleCentriX logo", "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hubfs/assets/images/peoplecentrix-logo.svg" }, "memberOf" : { "@type" : "Organization", "name" : "Swiss Triple Impact (B Lab Switzerland)", "url" : "https://www.swisstripleimpact.ch" }, "name" : "PeopleCentriX", "publishingPrinciples" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/how-we-work", "sameAs" : [ "https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoplecentrixconsulting" ], "slogan" : "People Strategy for Chief People Officers — defined, activated, proven. People Centricity for Chief Talent Officers — attracted, engaged, unleashed.", "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/en/" } ``` ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#tanguy-dulac", "@type" : "Person", "affiliation" : [ { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "Université de Fribourg", "url" : "https://www.unifr.ch" }, { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "Haute École de Gestion de Genève", "url" : "https://www.hesge.ch/heg" } ], "alumniOf" : [ { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "London School of Economics and Political Science", "url" : "https://www.lse.ac.uk" }, { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "Université catholique de Louvain", "url" : "https://uclouvain.be" } ], "description" : "Tanguy Dulac is the Founder & Managing Director of PeopleCentriX, an evidence-based people-strategy advisory in Switzerland, and Editor-in-Chief of WeAreHuman@Work, a weekly newsletter on sustainable work. More than 15,000 people follow him on LinkedIn. He holds a joint PhD in Applied Economics from the London School of Economics and the Université catholique de Louvain on the psychological contract — research published in the Academy of Management Journal and cited by more than 1,000 academic articles. He has built people strategies since 2006 at PwC, Deloitte and PeopleCentriX, across 72 engagements in 40 organisations, and lectures on Sustainable Human Capital Management at the University of Fribourg and on Human Capital Risk Management at the Haute École de Gestion de Genève.", "email" : "tanguy.dulac@peoplecentrix.eu", "familyName" : "Dulac", "givenName" : "Tanguy", "hasCredential" : [ { "@type" : "EducationalOccupationalCredential", "credentialCategory" : "PhD in Applied Economics", "recognizedBy" : [ { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "London School of Economics and Political Science" }, { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "Université catholique de Louvain" } ] }, { "@type" : "EducationalOccupationalCredential", "credentialCategory" : "MSc Applied Economics", "recognizedBy" : { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "Université catholique de Louvain" } }, { "@type" : "EducationalOccupationalCredential", "credentialCategory" : "MSc Organisational Psychology", "recognizedBy" : { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "Université catholique de Louvain" } } ], "hasOccupation" : [ { "@type" : "Occupation", "name" : "People strategy consultant" }, { "@type" : "Occupation", "name" : "University lecturer" }, { "@type" : "Occupation", "name" : "Newsletter editor" } ], "honorificSuffix" : "PhD", "image" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "caption" : "Tanguy Dulac, Founder & Managing Director of PeopleCentriX", "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hubfs/DSC09993.jpg" }, "jobTitle" : "Founder & Managing Director", "knowsAbout" : [ "People strategy", "People centricity", "Programme management", "Change management", "Business case", "HR metrics", "People analytics", "Employee attraction", "Employee experience", "Employee engagement", "Design thinking", "Human-centred design in HR", "HR operating model", "Human capital risk management", "People risks", "Human sustainability", "People sustainability", "Talent management", "Talent strategy" ], "knowsLanguage" : [ "fr", "en" ], "name" : "Tanguy Dulac", "nationality" : { "@type" : "Country", "name" : "Belgium" }, "sameAs" : [ "https://www.linkedin.com/in/tanguy-dulac", "https://www.wearehumanatwork.com", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=lE2o3sYAAAAJ" ], "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us", "worksFor" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#organization" } } ``` ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#amj-2008", "@type" : "ScholarlyArticle", "about" : "Psychological contract breach and violation", "author" : [ { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#tanguy-dulac" }, { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Jacqueline A-M. Coyle-Shapiro" }, { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "David J. Henderson" }, { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Sandy J. Wayne" } ], "datePublished" : "2008", "headline" : "Not All Responses to Breach Are the Same: The Interconnection of Social Exchange and Psychological Contract Processes in Organizations", "isPartOf" : { "@type" : "Periodical", "name" : "Academy of Management Journal" } } ``` ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@id" : "https://www.wearehumanatwork.com/#newsletter", "@type" : "Periodical", "description" : "A newsletter on sustainable work — Work with Purpose — edited by Tanguy Dulac.", "editor" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#tanguy-dulac" }, "inLanguage" : "en", "name" : "WeAreHuman@Work", "publisher" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#organization" }, "url" : "https://www.wearehumanatwork.com" } ``` ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#website", "@type" : "WebSite", "inLanguage" : "en", "name" : "PeopleCentriX", "publisher" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#organization" }, "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/en/" } ```