--- title: Same Behaviour, Different Ratings | Case Study description: How a multilateral organisation helped managers rate behaviour consistently and staff understand how they are rated, one contested scenario at a time. image: https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hubfs/social-sharing/cases/case-culture-and-performance-capability-building-at-a-multilateral-organisation.jpg --- [Skip to content](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/culture-and-performance-capability-building-at-a-multilateral-organisation#main-content) [![PeopleCentrix](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hubfs/assets/images/peoplecentrix-logo.svg "PeopleCentrix")](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/) [LET'S CONNECT →](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/work-with-us) - [People Strategy](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-strategy) - [People Centricity](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-centricity) - [How We Work](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/how-we-work) - [Insights](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-thinking) Show submenu for Insights - [Our Work](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) - [Our Thinking](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-thinking) - [About Us](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us) - [Work With Us](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/work-with-us) - [People Strategy](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-strategy) - [People Centricity](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-centricity) - [How We Work](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/how-we-work) - [Insights](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-thinking) Show submenu for Insights - [Our Work](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) - [Our Thinking](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-thinking) - [About Us](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us) - [Work With Us](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/work-with-us) Targeted Advisory case study # Same Behaviour, Different Ratings: *Blame the Boundary* **14**live sessions in 5 weeks, for supervisors and for staff **360+**supervisors and staff who rated the same scenarios **8**scenarios, each with an agreed and a contested reading **51/44**supervisors’ split at the hardest boundary, Good or Strong Snapshot Client A multilateral organisation (anonymised) Sector, size, geography International Public Sector; 1,000–2,500 staff; headquartered in Europe, serving member states worldwide Engagement Targeted Advisory · Performance Capability Our role Designed and facilitated the culture-goal capability programme with HR’s talent partners — scenario library, supervisor calibration track, staff track, live sessions, vote analysis, job aids and follow-up guides; roll-out by the client Mode of engagement Co-created Timeframe 2026 Project duration 1–3 months · 4 steps: find where the scale splits, 2 tracks for 2 jobs, run then redesign, read the votes; roll-out by the client The situation ## The question behind *the question.* This organisation had moved to a new performance framework in which half of every rating rests on behaviour. Each role type has one culture goal, rated on 5 levels, and strong results cannot lift the rating of someone whose behaviour falls short, so a manager’s reading of the scale can cap a strong performer. HR wanted managers who apply it consistently and fairly, and staff who understand how they are assessed. But a scale written in words is read in as many ways as there are readers. As it was asked “Train our managers and staff on culture goals.” As we reframed it Find where the scale splits its readers, let managers discover their own disagreements before ratings count, and show staff how they are rated and what they can do about it. How we worked ## How the work *unfolded.* 01 ### Find where the scale splits We started from the scale, not from slides: where would 2 fair managers read the same behaviour differently? With HR’s talent partners we wrote 8 scenarios. Each had an anchor reading most people should agree on, contested readings near the boundaries between levels, and an expected vote split written down in advance, so the room’s result could be read against it. Real cases, contract consequences and conduct issues stayed out, so people could disagree safely. 02 ### 2 tracks for 2 jobs Then 2 tracks for 2 jobs. Supervisors calibrated: rate a scenario alone, compare in pairs, see the room’s vote, through lenses on bias, culture and neurodiversity, the last shaped with the inclusion team: am I scoring what they did, or how it looked to me? Each left with 1 evidence statement drafted and 1 personal commitment. Staff learned how the rating works from a facilitator independent of HR, with silent reflection, questions by chat and a demo of where evidence is recorded. 03 ### Run, then redesign Then live, online sessions of 90 minutes rather than the 2 hours requested, because attention fades before the second hour, deliberately not recorded and grouped by sector where possible. A dry run with the talent partners came first. After the first real session we redesigned overnight: scenario first, framework second, because people engaged with a case before a definition. 14 sessions in 5 weeks reached more than 360 people in one window. 04 ### Read the votes Then the votes, read as data. “Subjectivity” was the first word for both groups, from 42% of staff and 33% of supervisors, but consistency worried 13% of supervisors and almost no staff: one fear, seen from both sides of the desk. On clear cases, 2 in 3 agreed. At the line between good and strong, supervisors split 51 to 44 on the same behaviour: that boundary, not the definitions, needed calibrating. The questions raised became job aids, guides and FAQs. The instrument ### Rate, compare, reveal **Rate alone.** Each manager rates the same scenario privately, before hearing anyone else. **Compare in pairs.** 2 managers explain their ratings to each other, evidence first. **Reveal the room.** The vote appears; the split shows where the scale needs a shared reading. Consistency is not taught. It is discovered, one disagreement at a time. What moved ## What changed, *and what didn't.* **360+**supervisors and staff rated the same scenarios on the same scale, in 14 live sessions Evidence Decision taken Adopted in practice Measured impact What moved **360+** supervisors and staff worked through the same scenarios on the same scale. HR now uses what the sessions produced: job aids for both tracks, the scenario library to calibrate ratings, guides on the culture goal and its evidence, and FAQs built from the questions people actually asked. What didn't move The engagement closed with 14 of the 20 planned sessions delivered: the other 6, and a session for senior leaders, were not run. The only data were the votes in the room: no check yet of how culture-goal ratings spread at year-end. Sessions ran in English only, live only, with no train-the-trainer for HR. What we'd say to a peer A rating scale written in words is read in as many ways as there are managers. Staff will call it subjective; managers will call it inconsistent. Before the cycle, let managers rate the same cases privately and see where they split: the hardest boundary, not the definitions, is what to train. And explain the rating to staff through someone who does not do the rating. [Let's talk](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/work-with-us) [Read more cases](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) **Method note:** Own approach in 4 steps; 8-scenario library with anchor and contested readings; private rating, pair comparison and live vote; bias, culture and neurodiversity lenses; job aids, guides and FAQs. ## Keep reading [![Who to Keep? Rate the Post and the Person Separately](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hs-fs/hubfs/social-sharing/cases/case-critical-positions-and-succession-management-at-a-multilateral-organisation.jpg?width=300&name=case-critical-positions-and-succession-management-at-a-multilateral-organisation.jpg)](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/critical-positions-and-succession-management-at-a-multilateral-organisation) ###### [Our Work,](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work)[Case Study](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) ##### [Who to Keep? Rate the Post and the Person Separately](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/critical-positions-and-succession-management-at-a-multilateral-organisation) [Tanguy Dulac](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us) [Read More](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/critical-positions-and-succession-management-at-a-multilateral-organisation) [![The Leavers the Talent Review Said Would Stay](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hs-fs/hubfs/social-sharing/cases/case-voluntary-turnover-analysis-at-a-financial-services-firm.jpg?width=300&name=case-voluntary-turnover-analysis-at-a-financial-services-firm.jpg)](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/voluntary-turnover-analysis-at-a-financial-services-firm) ###### [Our Work,](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work)[Case Study](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) ##### [The Leavers the Talent Review Said Would Stay](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/voluntary-turnover-analysis-at-a-financial-services-firm) [Tanguy Dulac](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us) [Read More](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/voluntary-turnover-analysis-at-a-financial-services-firm) [![Before the HR Platform Locks In](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hs-fs/hubfs/social-sharing/cases/case-hr-platform-implementation-scoping-at-a-multilateral-organisation.jpg?width=300&name=case-hr-platform-implementation-scoping-at-a-multilateral-organisation.jpg)](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/hr-platform-implementation-scoping-at-a-multilateral-organisation) ###### [Our Work,](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work)[Case Study](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) ##### [Before the HR Platform Locks In](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/hr-platform-implementation-scoping-at-a-multilateral-organisation) [Tanguy Dulac](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us) [Read More](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/blog/hr-platform-implementation-scoping-at-a-multilateral-organisation) WeAreHuman@Work One piece of evidence on sustainable work, every Sunday. Free, and one click to leave. [Get the weekly edition](https://www.wearehumanatwork.com/) ##### ![logo-white-ls-sample-theme](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hubfs/raw_assets/public/popular-theme-v2/assets/images/peoplecentrix-footer-logo.svg) We help HR leaders turn people investment into measurable results — strategies that get approved, interventions that get delivered, impact that gets proven. ##### Follow Us [Follow us on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoplecentrixconsulting/) ##### Quick Links - [Home](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/en/) - [People Strategy](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-strategy) - [People Centricity](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-centricity) - [How We Work](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/how-we-work) - [Our Client Case Studies](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-work) - [Our Thinking](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/our-thinking) - [About Us](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us) - [Work With Us](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/work-with-us) ##### Contact PeopleCentriX Geneva, Switzerland    [tanguy.dulac@peoplecentrix.eu](mailto:info@peoplecentrix.eu) --- Copyright © 2026 PeopleCentriX SARL. All rights reserved. PeopleCentriX name and logo are registered trademarks of PeopleCentriX SARL. - [Privacy statement](https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/en/privacy-page) ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#organization", "@type" : [ "ProfessionalService", "Organization" ], "address" : { "@type" : "PostalAddress", "addressCountry" : "CH", "addressLocality" : "Founex", "addressRegion" : "Vaud", "postalCode" : "1297", "streetAddress" : "Chemin du Lac 19A" }, "alternateName" : [ "PeopleCentriX Consulting", "PeopleCentriX SARL" ], "areaServed" : [ "Worldwide", "International organisations", "Private sector", "Public sector" ], "audience" : [ { "@type" : "Audience", "audienceType" : "Chief People Officers and Chief Human Resources Officers" }, { "@type" : "Audience", "audienceType" : "Chief Talent Officers and Heads of Talent Management" } ], "contactPoint" : { "@type" : "ContactPoint", "availableLanguage" : [ "English", "French" ], "contactType" : "sales", "email" : "tanguy.dulac@peoplecentrix.eu", "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/work-with-us" }, "description" : "PeopleCentriX is an evidence-based people-strategy advisory founded in Switzerland in March 2022 by Tanguy Dulac, PhD. It serves Chief People Officers defining, activating and proving a board-approved people strategy, and Chief Talent Officers attracting, engaging and unleashing talent through focused people-centricity interventions. It helps both turn people investment into measurable results — strategies that get approved, interventions that get delivered, impact that gets proven.", "email" : "tanguy.dulac@peoplecentrix.eu", "employee" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#tanguy-dulac" }, "founder" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#tanguy-dulac" }, "foundingDate" : "2022-03", "foundingLocation" : { "@type" : "Place", "name" : "Founex, Vaud, Switzerland" }, "hasOfferCatalog" : { "@type" : "OfferCatalog", "itemListElement" : [ { "@type" : "Offer", "itemOffered" : { "@type" : "Service", "audience" : { "@type" : "Audience", "audienceType" : "Chief People Officers" }, "description" : "Define, Activate, Prove — the sparring partner for the Chief People Officer carrying the board mandate: build the evidence base and business case, govern implementation from inside the programme office, and prove what the investment returned against baselines set before the work starts.", "name" : "People Strategy", "provider" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#organization" }, "serviceType" : "People strategy advisory", "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-strategy" } }, { "@type" : "Offer", "itemOffered" : { "@type" : "Service", "audience" : { "@type" : "Audience", "audienceType" : "Chief Talent Officers" }, "description" : "Attract, Engage, Unleash — focused interventions for Chief Talent Officers, each targeting one component of the People Centricity Formula™: an employee value proposition built on researched expectations, moments that matter redesigned, and talent frameworks that develop potential. Closed when solved.", "name" : "People Centricity", "provider" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#organization" }, "serviceType" : "Talent and employee-experience interventions", "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/people-centricity" } } ], "name" : "PeopleCentriX offerings" }, "image" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hubfs/assets/images/peoplecentrix-logo.svg", "knowsAbout" : [ "People strategy", "People centricity", "Programme management", "Change management", "Business case", "HR metrics", "People analytics", "Employee attraction", "Employee experience", "Employee engagement", "Design thinking", "Human-centred design in HR", "HR operating model", "Human capital risk management", "People risks", "Human sustainability", "People sustainability", "Talent management", "Talent strategy" ], "knowsLanguage" : [ "en", "fr" ], "legalName" : "PeopleCentriX Sàrl", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "caption" : "PeopleCentriX logo", "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hubfs/assets/images/peoplecentrix-logo.svg" }, "memberOf" : { "@type" : "Organization", "name" : "Swiss Triple Impact (B Lab Switzerland)", "url" : "https://www.swisstripleimpact.ch" }, "name" : "PeopleCentriX", "publishingPrinciples" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/how-we-work", "sameAs" : [ "https://www.linkedin.com/company/peoplecentrixconsulting" ], "slogan" : "People Strategy for Chief People Officers — defined, activated, proven. People Centricity for Chief Talent Officers — attracted, engaged, unleashed.", "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/en/" } ``` ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#tanguy-dulac", "@type" : "Person", "affiliation" : [ { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "Université de Fribourg", "url" : "https://www.unifr.ch" }, { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "Haute École de Gestion de Genève", "url" : "https://www.hesge.ch/heg" } ], "alumniOf" : [ { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "London School of Economics and Political Science", "url" : "https://www.lse.ac.uk" }, { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "Université catholique de Louvain", "url" : "https://uclouvain.be" } ], "description" : "Tanguy Dulac is the Founder & Managing Director of PeopleCentriX, an evidence-based people-strategy advisory in Switzerland, and Editor-in-Chief of WeAreHuman@Work, a weekly newsletter on sustainable work. More than 15,000 people follow him on LinkedIn. He holds a joint PhD in Applied Economics from the London School of Economics and the Université catholique de Louvain on the psychological contract — research published in the Academy of Management Journal and cited by more than 1,000 academic articles. He has built people strategies since 2006 at PwC, Deloitte and PeopleCentriX, across 72 engagements in 40 organisations, and lectures on Sustainable Human Capital Management at the University of Fribourg and on Human Capital Risk Management at the Haute École de Gestion de Genève.", "email" : "tanguy.dulac@peoplecentrix.eu", "familyName" : "Dulac", "givenName" : "Tanguy", "hasCredential" : [ { "@type" : "EducationalOccupationalCredential", "credentialCategory" : "PhD in Applied Economics", "recognizedBy" : [ { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "London School of Economics and Political Science" }, { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "Université catholique de Louvain" } ] }, { "@type" : "EducationalOccupationalCredential", "credentialCategory" : "MSc Applied Economics", "recognizedBy" : { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "Université catholique de Louvain" } }, { "@type" : "EducationalOccupationalCredential", "credentialCategory" : "MSc Organisational Psychology", "recognizedBy" : { "@type" : "CollegeOrUniversity", "name" : "Université catholique de Louvain" } } ], "hasOccupation" : [ { "@type" : "Occupation", "name" : "People strategy consultant" }, { "@type" : "Occupation", "name" : "University lecturer" }, { "@type" : "Occupation", "name" : "Newsletter editor" } ], "honorificSuffix" : "PhD", "image" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "caption" : "Tanguy Dulac, Founder & Managing Director of PeopleCentriX", "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/hubfs/DSC09993.jpg" }, "jobTitle" : "Founder & Managing Director", "knowsAbout" : [ "People strategy", "People centricity", "Programme management", "Change management", "Business case", "HR metrics", "People analytics", "Employee attraction", "Employee experience", "Employee engagement", "Design thinking", "Human-centred design in HR", "HR operating model", "Human capital risk management", "People risks", "Human sustainability", "People sustainability", "Talent management", "Talent strategy" ], "knowsLanguage" : [ "fr", "en" ], "name" : "Tanguy Dulac", "nationality" : { "@type" : "Country", "name" : "Belgium" }, "sameAs" : [ "https://www.linkedin.com/in/tanguy-dulac", "https://www.wearehumanatwork.com", "https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=lE2o3sYAAAAJ" ], "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/about-us", "worksFor" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#organization" } } ``` ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#amj-2008", "@type" : "ScholarlyArticle", "about" : "Psychological contract breach and violation", "author" : [ { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#tanguy-dulac" }, { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Jacqueline A-M. Coyle-Shapiro" }, { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "David J. Henderson" }, { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Sandy J. Wayne" } ], "datePublished" : "2008", "headline" : "Not All Responses to Breach Are the Same: The Interconnection of Social Exchange and Psychological Contract Processes in Organizations", "isPartOf" : { "@type" : "Periodical", "name" : "Academy of Management Journal" } } ``` ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@id" : "https://www.wearehumanatwork.com/#newsletter", "@type" : "Periodical", "description" : "A newsletter on sustainable work — Work with Purpose — edited by Tanguy Dulac.", "editor" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#tanguy-dulac" }, "inLanguage" : "en", "name" : "WeAreHuman@Work", "publisher" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#organization" }, "url" : "https://www.wearehumanatwork.com" } ``` ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#website", "@type" : "WebSite", "inLanguage" : "en", "name" : "PeopleCentriX", "publisher" : { "@id" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/#organization" }, "url" : "https://www.peoplecentrix.eu/en/" } ```